It came
to mind when I received an email about anti-GMO crusader Jeffrey
Smith's Hawaii tour later this week, which comes on the heels of a
similar circuit taken by anti-atrazine researcher Tyrone Hayes, who is
speaking tomorrow night on Kauai.
On the
poster, Smith is described as “one of the most saught [sic] after,
internationally recognized voices of GMO Truth.” One of his Maui
talks is pitched as “an event of truth and facts,” while the
other is described as “A Day of GMO Truth.” Curiously, no such
claim is made for his Kauai appearance, which is listed simply as a
“GMO community talk.”
And I
thought, how can you possibly pretend you are serving up truth when you are presenting just one point of view? Which is when I
was again reminded of how the anti-GMO movement has assumed all the
self-righteous, one-way, one-truth fervor of the evangelicals —
replete with swooning. I'll never forget the 2491 testimony of the
lady who said she ate a GMO papaya “and fainted dead away.”
So it is
clear now that in Hawaii, we will not be able to have a reasonable
public discussion on this issue. We will not be able to publicly
debate different sets of facts, varying versions of the truth.
In the current socio-political milieu, you're
either a true believer, or a heretic, with absolutely no middle ground allowed.
Meanwhile,
real life continues in its many, often contradictory, shades of gray.
Parking for Hayes' UH-Hilo talk was disrupted due to construction of
a chemical storage building on campus. Dow, denounced as a demonic
defiler, made the pesticide Vikane that was used this past week to
treat a Singapore ant infestation on the Hokulea.
Billionaire
Pierre Omidyar is blasted for bankrolling a dairy on Kauai, a project
deemed unsustainable because the cows won't eat organic feed and the
milk will be shipped to Oahu for processing. Billionaire Larry Ellis
is lauded for using Lanai's scarce water to grow organic veggies that
will be shipped to China and Japan.
Always, we are grouping into good-bad, right-wrong, us-them.
Which
brings me to a blog post well-written by Luke Evslin, who has one of
the more interesting minds on this island, largely because he
actually uses it to think, instead of parrot or echo or regurgitate
or deny. He wrote:
Since we
can witness and measure an obvious environmental decline, then it
only makes sense that the culprit is the way we currently run
society. That's our enemy.
There's
only one problem; that's us. We embody the status-quo everytime we
get into our car. Everytime we ingest food that comes from a
grocery store. Everytime we put on a t-shirt. Everytime
we cast a vote for either a democrat or a republican. But what
else can we do?
We all
can see it. We all complain about it. We all want to do
something about it. But that's as far as we can go. We've
failed at even approaching a solution because we are the problem.
We can't look to the Civil Rights movement and sit at a lunch counter
in Birmingham or look to the Indian Nationalist movement and go on a
hunger strike in a British prison. The two most successful
social movements of the last century had tangible enemies. And
non-violent resistance worked because of that. As we perpetuate
the greatest environmental crime (climate change) in history, we are
our own enemy. And there's nothing that we can do to divest
ourselves.
So, back
to my struggling question of last week, what now? How do we envision
a different future? How do we change the system?
I certainly don't
have all the answers, or maybe even any, but I think one place to
start is to stop taking refuge in the “me good, you bad" bang-and blame duality mindset. All of us are the problem, and all
of us can play a role in the solution.
Luke
writes, correctly and coherently:
Our
failure isn't caused by incessant growth or a reliance on technology.
We are failing because capitalism can not adequately value the
environment. There is an intrinsic worth to nature which can not be
quantified.
Luisa Kolker, a shamanic healer I interviewed yesterday, added another
piece:
We need
to find ways to re-attune with our own inner wilderness.We've lost
the empathic connection with ourselves, and with the Earth. Until we
are in good relationship with ourselves, we will defile and violate
nature.
Meanwhile,
as astrologer Stephanie Azaria points out, there is a powerful
metaphor currently at work as scientists uncover the ancient remains of the
largest known animal to walk on Earth, a creature that was 65 feet
high — equal to a seven-story building — and 130 feet long:
We all
know what a dinosaur is, in esoteric talk. For those of you who don’t
know, a dinosaur is a consciousness that is infused with the old,
outdated way of being. The dictionary describes it this way: a person
or thing that is outdated or has become obsolete because of failure
to adapt to changing circumstances.
Dinosaurs, like the ruined remnants of fallen civilizations, remind
us anew that we aren't too big to fail.
The
choice is ours: work together to figure out how we can adapt
ourselves and our civilization to fit the natural ecological
constraints of this planet, or continue to pursue the dinosaur mindset of separation and
polarization, cloaked in the false belief that some one of has a
lock on “The Truth.”
"Musings: Fact and Fancy"
9 Comments - Show Original Post Collapse comments
This has been happening for years. The County of Kauai is irresponsible and reckless with the budget. Looking back when Lenny Rapozo couldn't do his job so they hired a consultant for over 100k to tell him what needs to be done to the Kilauea gym is alarming as this CASHING OUT scheme. What has been done?
The parks and recs as well as our highways are in shambles. These so called appointed positions with over 100k salaries are a travesty and yet the county posts new jobs on Kauai Jobs Indeed every week to the tune of 6-10 jobs. Why is the County of Kauai raising taxes and so irresponsible with governing?
Why are we still putting public money into that property, especially when there are other pressing needs? Like, say, environmental pesticide sampling, or public health studies that might put some minds at ease.
This is also in regards to the alternate transportation route (Bike Path BS), Why is Joann extensively pushing for this project? who is going to cash out on this one?
The same could be said for the 2-3 mile stretch of highway from Puhi to the old Lihue mill bridge that's been going on for 4 years. This is as obvious as the Wailua bridge cost scandal as it gets.
The pot holes all around the island destroys people vehicles. They are so dangerous that not only vehicle damage could occur but accidents and accidents that kill people and families is going to happen. All the while we can take pictures and put thrash as moments from Fukushima as tokens of relations.
Streams in urban Oahu had the highest number of pesticides present, including one site where 20 types were detected. In total, the study found 41 pesticide compounds.
There are already Universities and organizations properly trained, experienced and qualified to test and study our water, air, soil, and foliage for pesticides that are toxic. The proposal of a county having a committee of (probably untrained family and friends) people to do a 20-30 year study is ludicrous. It's all about creating more nepotism.
We have to CHANGE the STATUS QUO, end the GOBAG regime, and find well educated, trained, experienced, and people with integrity to govern Kauai.
Mayor Carvahlo and his cronies has to GO. If anyone running for Mayor guarantees that if elected as Mayor they will have a selection process to elect a county manager then I will support that candidate.
We have to cut the PORK out of our budget and that means non essential county employees. This county's budget has risen 40-80 million since Carvalho has taken over. That's over 10 million a year that the common folk has to fork the bill.
Now is the time where we have to VOTE wisely, like we did in the prosecuting attorneys election. We will be better off than what we have as our current county officials.
But hey, thanks for confirming that no, we won't see an end to the hysteria.
I have it on a very good and supreme authority, Gary Hooser. Gary has said that there are indeed, dangerous amounts of of poison in the water. He is an expert as a former Senator, former Environmental big shot and current Council person, he has big time insider knowledge on poisons and what not. He would never ever, not in a hundred thousand years, deceive his public.
As far as Coco Palms study kala goes...anyone with a basic concept of money and return knows that this project will never happen and the Council fell for a couple of Realtors trying to keep a project alive so they get couple million dollar sales commission. The Council should have mandated that in order to get grand-fathered on the Iniki Building permits the developers should take down the existing structure by xxx date and then after the demolition, the prepared building permit would be given into their greedy little mittens.
I think we are all agreed Hooser is no expert, well except maybe on how to use fear and lies to completely screw over a county. But pesticides? definitely not.